THE HOLY DOOR Polly Donegan and Nora Lawlor met every morning after eight o’clock Mass. They were both good-living girls; indeed, they were among the best girls in town. Nora had a round soft face and great round wondering eyes. She was inquisitive, shy, and a dreamer—an awkward combination. Her father, a builder called Jerry Lawlor, had been vice-commandant of the Volunteers during the Troubles. Polly was tall, with coal-black hair, a long, proud, striking face, and an air of great calm and resolution. As they went down the hill from the church she saluted everyone with an open pleasant smile and accepted whatever invitations she got. Nora went through the torments of the damned whenever anyone invited her anywhere; curiosity and timidity combined made her visualize every consequence of accepting or not accepting, down to the last detail. Now Nora, with that peculiar trait in her make-up, had a knack which Polly found very disconcerting of bringing the conversation round to the facts of life. To Nora the facts of life were the ultimate invitation; acceptance meant never-ending embarrassment, refusal a curiosity unsatisfied till death. While she struggled to put her complex in words Polly adopted a blank and polite air and without the least effort retreated into her own thoughts of what they should have for dinner. “You’re not listening to a word I say,” Nora said on a note of complaint. “Oh, I am, Nora, I am,” Polly said impatiently. “But I’ll have to be rushing or I’ll be late for breakfast.” Nora could see that Polly wasn’t even interested in the facts of life. She wondered a lot about that. Was Polly natural? Was it possible not to be curious? Was she only acting sly like all the Donegans? Nora had thought so long about God’s inscrutable purpose in creating mankind in two sexes that she could hardly see the statue of a saint without wondering what he’d be like without his clothes. That was no joke in our church, where there are statues inside the door and in each of the sidechapels and along the columns of the arcade. It makes the church quite gay, but it was a terrible temptation to Nora, who found it hard not to see them all like Greek statues, and whatever it was about their faces and gestures they seemed worse like that than any Greek divinities. To the truly pious mind there is something appalling in the idea of St. Aloysius Gonzaga without his clothes. That particular notion struck Polly as the height of nonsense. “Wisha, Nora,” she said with suppressed fury, “what things you think about!” “But after all,” retorted Nora with a touch of fire, “they must have had bodies like the rest of us.” “Why then indeed, Nora, they’d be very queer without them,” said Polly serenely, and it was clear to Nora that she hadn’t a glimmer. “Anyway, what has it to do with us?” “You might find it has a lot to do with you when you get married,” said Nora darkly. “Ah, well, it’ll never worry me so,” said Polly confidently. “Why, Polly? Won’t you ever get married?” “What a thing I’d do!” said Polly. “But why, Polly?” asked Nora eagerly, hoping that at last she might discover some point where Polly’s fastidiousness met her own. “Ah,” Polly sighed, “I could never imagine myself married. No matters how fond of them you’d be. Like Susie. I always hated sharing a room with Susie. She was never done talking.” “Oh, if talking was all that was in it!” exclaimed Nora with a dark brightness like a smile. “I think talking is the worst of all, Nora,” Polly said firmly. “I can’t imagine anything worse.” “There’s a shock in store for you if you do marry,” said Nora darkly. “What sort of shock, Nora?” asked Polly. “Oh, of course, you can’t even describe it,” said Nora fretfully “No one will even tell you. People you knew all your life go on as if you were only a child and couldn’t be told.” “Do they really, Nora?” Polly said with a giggle, inspired less by thought of what the mystery could be than by that of Nora’s inquisitiveness brought to a full stop for once. “If you get married before me will you tell me?” Nora asked. “Oh, I will to be sure, girl,” said Polly in the tone of one promising to let her know when the coal man came. “But I mean everything, Polly,” Nora said earnestly. “Oh, why wouldn’t I, Nora?” Polly cried impatiently, showing that Nora’s preoccupation with the facts of life struck her as being uncalled-for. “Anyway, you’re more likely to be married than I am. Somehow I never had any inclination for it.” It was clear that her sister’s garrulity had blighted some man’s chance of Polly. II Charlie Cashman was a great friend of Nora’s father and a regular visitor to her home. He had been her father’s Commandant during the Troubles. He owned the big hardware store in town and this he owed entirely to his good national record. He and his mother had never got on, for she hated the Volunteers as she hated the books he read; she looked on him as a flighty fellow and had determined early in his life that the shop would go to her second son, John Joe. As Mrs. Cashman was a woman who had never known what it was not to have her own way, Charlie had resigned himself to this, and after the Troubles, cleared out and worked as a shop assistant in Asragh. But then old John Cashman died, having never in his liftime contradicted his wife, and his will was found to be nothing but a contradiction. It seemed that he had always been a violent nationalist and admired culture and hated John Joe, and Charlie, as in the novels, got every damn thing, even his mother being left in the house only on sufferance. Charlie was a good catch and there was no doubt of his liking for Nora, but somehow Nora couldn’t bear him. He was an airy, excitable man with a plump, sallow, wrinkled face that always looked as if it needed shaving, a pair of keen grey eyes in slits under bushy brows; hair on his cheekbones, hair in his ears, hair even in his nose. He wore a dirty old tweed suit and a cap. Nora couldn’t stand him—even with his clothes on. She told herself that it was the cleft in his chin, which someone had once told her betokened a sensual nature, but it was really the thought of all the hair. It made him look so animal! Besides, there was something sly and double-meaning about him. He was, by town standards, a very well-read man. Once he found Nora reading St. Francis de Sales and asked her if she’d ever read Romeo and Juliet with such a knowing air that he roused her dislike even further. She gave him a cold and penetrating look which should have crushed him but didn’t—he was so thick. “As a matter of fact I have,” she said steadily, just to show him that true piety did not exclude a study of the grosser aspects of life. “What did you think of it?” he asked. “I thought it contained a striking moral lesson,” said Nora. “Go on!” Charlie exclaimed with a grin. “What was that, Nora?” “It showed where unrestrained passion can carry people,” she said. “Ah, I wouldn’t notice that,” said Charlie. “Your father and myself were a bit wild too, in our time.” Her father, a big, pop-eyed, open-gobbed man, looked at them both and said nothing, but he knew from their tone that they were sparring across him and he wanted to know more about it. That night after Charlie had gone he looked at Nora with a terrible air. “What’s that book Charlie Cashman was talking about?” he asked. “Did I read that?” “Romeo and Juliet?” she said with a start. “It’s there on the shelf behind you. In the big Shakespeare.” Jerry took down the book and looked even more astonished. “That’s a funny way to write a book,” he said. “What is it about?” She told him the story as well as she could, with a slight tendency to make Friar Laurence the hero, and her father looked more pop-eyed than ever. He had a proper respect for culture. “But they were married all right?” he asked at last. “They were,” said Nora. “Why?” “Ah, that was a funny way to take him up so,” her father said cantankerously. “’isn’t as if there was anything wrong in it.” He went to the foot of the stairs with his hands in his trouser pockets while Nora watched him with a hypnotised air. She knew what he was thinking of. “Mind,” he said, “I’m not trying to force him on you, but there’s plenty of girls in this town would be glad of your chance.” That was all he said but Nora wanted no chances. She would have preferred to die in the arena like a Christian martyr sooner than marry a man with so much hair. She never even gave Charlie the opportunity of proposing, though she knew her father and he had discussed it between themselves. And then, to her utter disgust, Charlie transferred his attentions to Polly, whom he had met at her house. Of course, her disgust had nothing to do with jealousy of Polly. Mainly it was inspired by the revelation it afforded of masculine character, particularly of Charlie’s. Sensual, flighty, he had not had the decency to remain a celibate for the rest of his life; he hadn’t threatened suicide, hadn’t even to be taken away for a long holiday by his friends. He merely cut his losses as though she were a type of car he couldn’t afford and took the next cheapest. It left her depressed about human nature in general. Only too well had her father gauged the situation. Not only did the Donegans go all-out to capture Charlie but Polly herself seemed quite pleased. After all she had said against marriage, this struck Nora as sly. In more judicious moments she knew she was not being quite fair to Polly. The truth was probably that Polly, being a good-natured, dutiful girl, felt if she were to marry at all, she should do so in such a way as to oblige her family. She did not mind the hair and had a genuine liking for Charlie. She was a modest girl who made no claim to brains; she never even knew which of the two parties was the government of the moment, and Charlie could explain it all to her in the most interesting way. To her he seemed a man of really gigantic intellect, and listening to him was like listening to a great preacher. Yet, even admitting all this, Nora thought her conduct pretty strange. The Donegans were all sly. It caused a certain coldness between the two girls, but Polly was self-centred and hardhearted and Nora got the worst of that. III Like all young brides-to-be, Polly was full of plans. When Charlie asked where they should go on their honeymoon she looked troubled. “Ah, ’twould cost too much,” she said in her tangential way. “What would cost too much, girl?” Charlie replied recklessly. “Never mind what it costs. Where do you want to go?” “Lourdes?” Polly asked, half as a question. “Is that far, Charlie?” “Lourdes,” repeated Charlie in bewilderment. “What do you want to go to Lourdes for?” “Oh, only for the sake of the pilgrimage,” said Polly. “You never read _The Life of Bernadette_, Charlie?” “Never,” said Charlie promptly, in dread he was going to be compelled to read it. “We’ll go to Lourdes.” It was all arranged when one day Polly and Nora met in the street. Nora was self-conscious; she was thinking of all the things she had said of Charlie to Polly and certain they had got back (they hadn’t, but Nora judged by herself). “Where are ye going for the honeymoon?” she asked. “You’d never guess,” replied Polly joyously. “Where?” Nora asked, her eyes beginning to pop. “Lourdes, imagine!” “Lourdes?” cried Nora aghast. “But didn’t you know?” “Know what, Nora?” Polly asked, alarmed in her turn. “Don’t tell me ’tis forbidden.” “’Tisn’t that at all but ’tis unlucky,” said Nora breathlessly. “I only knew one girl that did it and she died inside a year.” “Oh, Law, Nora,” Polly cried with bitter disappointment, “how is it nobody told me that, or what sort of people do they have in those travel agencies?” “I suppose they took it for granted you’d know,” said Nora. “How _could_ I know, Nora?” Polly cried despairingly. “Even Charlie doesn’t know, and he’s supposed to be an educated man.” Away she rushed to challenge Charlie and they had their first big row. Charlie was now reconciled to Lourdes by the prospect of a few days in Paris, and he stamped and fumed about Nora Lawlor and her blasted pishrogues, but you did not catch a prudent girl like Polly risking fortune and happiness by defying the will of God, and a few days before the wedding everything was cancelled. They went to Connemara instead. They arrived there on a wet evening and Polly said dismally that it wasn’t in the least like what she expected. This was not the only thing that failed to come up to expectations, nor was hers the only disappointment. She had brought a little statue of the Blessed Virgin and put it on the table by her bed. Then she said her night prayers and undressed. She was rather surprised at the way Charlie looked at her but not really upset. She was exhausted after the journey and remarked to Charlie on the comfort of the bed. “Oh,” she said with a yawn, “I don’t think there’s anything in the world like bed.” At this Charlie gave her a wolfish grin, not like any grin she’d ever seen before, and it filled her with alarm. “Oh, Charlie, what did I say?” she asked. Charlie didn’t reply, which was still more alarming; he got into bed beside her and she gave a loud gasp that could be heard right through the hotel. For the rest of the night her brain, not usually retentive of ideas, had room only for one. “Can it be? Is it possible? Why did nobody tell me?” She kept herself from flying out of the room in hysterics only by repeating aspirations like “Jesus, mercy! Mary, help!” She thought of all the married women she had known from her mother on—fat pious, good-natured women you saw every morning at Mass—and wondered if they had lived all those years with such a secret in their hearts. Now she knew exactly what Nora had been trying to find out and why no one had ever told her. It was something that couldn’t be told, only endured. One faint hope remained; that after years she might get used to it as the others seemed to have done. But then it all began again and she muttered aspirations to herself loud enough for Charlie to hear, and knew she could never, never get used to it; and when it was over a bitter anger smouldered in her against all the nonsense that had been written about it by old gasbags like Shakespeare. “Oh, what liars they are!” she thought, wishing she could just lay hands on one of them for five minutes. “What liars!” The day after they returned from the honeymoon Nora called. She had managed to bottle her curiosity just so far. Charlie was in the shop and she smiled shyly at him. Polly and herself sat in the best room overlooking the Main Street and had their tea. Nora noticed with satisfaction that she looked a bit haggard. Then Nora lit a cigarette and sat back. “And what does it feel like to be married?” she asked with a smile. “Oh, all right, Nora,” Polly replied, though for a moment her face looked more haggard than before. “And how do you find Charlie?” “Oh, much like anyone else, I suppose,” Polly said doubtfully, and her eyes strayed in the direction of the window. “And is that all you’re going to tell us?” Nora went on with a nervous laugh. “Oh, whatever do you mean, Nora?” Polly asked indignantly. “I thought you were going to advise me,” Nora said lightly, though with a growing feeling that there was nothing to be got out of Polly. “Oh, Law, Nora,” Polly said with a distraught air, “I don’t think it can ever be right to talk about things like that.” Nora knew she would never get anything out of Polly. She would never get anything out of anybody. They were all the same. They went inside and the door closed behind them forever. She felt like crying. “Was it as bad as that?” she asked with chagrin. “I think I’d sooner not talk about it at all, Nora,” Polly said firmly. She bowed her head; her smooth forehead became fenced with wrinkles and a second chin began to peep from beneath the first. IV Charlie’s shop was on Main Street; a store like a cave, with buckets and spades hanging and stacked at either side of the opening. When you went in there was hardware on your right and the general store on the left. Charlie looked after the hardware and Polly and a girl assistant after the rest. Charlie’s end of it was really well run; there wasn’t a bit of agricultural machinery for miles around that he didn’t know the workings of and for which, at a pinch, he couldn’t produce at least the substitute for a spare part. Polly wasn’t brilliant in that way, but she was conscientious and polite. In every way she was all a wife should be; obliging, sweet-tempered, good-humoured, and so modest that she wouldn’t even allow Charlie to put on the light while she dressed for Mass on a winter morning. Mrs. Cashman had always had a great selection of holy pictures but Polly had brought a whole gallery with her. There was also a Lourdes clock which played the Lourdes hymn at the Angelus hours—very soothing and devotional—but at the same time Charlie was just the least bit disappointed. He was disappointed and he couldn’t say why. “Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou, Romeo?” he would suddenly find himself declaiming about nothing at all. Italian women were probably different. No doubt it was the sun! He was a restless man and he had hoped marriage would settle him. It hadn’t settled him. When he had closed the shop for the night and should have been sitting upstairs with his book and his pipe, the longing would suddenly seize him to go out to Johnny Desmond’s pub instead. He would walk in and out the hall and peer up and down the street till the restlessness became too much for him. It was all very disconcerting. Sometimes for consolation he went back to the shop, switched on the lamp over his desk, and took out the copy of his father’s will. This was the will from which he had expected nothing and which gave him everything. He read it through again with a reverent expression. He had always liked the will; admired its massive style, the way it carefully excluded all possibility of misunderstanding; it had given him a new respect for lawyers; indeed, in its own way it was as powerful as Shakespeare. One murky, gloomy afternoon when business had stopped his mother came in and found him at it. He gave her a sly grin. She was a cranky, crafty, monotonous old woman, twisted with rheumatics and malice. “I was just saying my office,” he said. “Oh, I see what you’re at,” she said with resignation. “I saw it long ago.” “Fine, devotional reading!” said Charlie, slapping a hairy paw on the will. “Go on, you blasphemous bosthoon!” she said without rancour. “You were always too smart for your poor slob of a brother. But take care you wouldn’t be keeping the bed warm for him yet!” “What’s that you say?” asked Charlie, startled. “God spoke first,” intoned his mother. “Many a better cake didn’t rise.” She went out, banging the door behind her, and left Charlie gasping, naked to the cruel day. The will had lost its magical power. There was one clause in it to which he had never paid attention—there never had been any reason why he should do so—entailing the shop on his children, and, failing those, on John Joe’s. And John Joe had four with another coming while Charlie still had none. Another man only a year married wouldn’t have given it a thought but Charlie wasn’t that kind. The man was a born worrier. With his hands in his pockets he paced moodily to the shop door and stood there, leaning against the jamb, his legs crossed and his cap pulled down over his eyes. His mother read him like a book. The least thing was enough to set him off. At the first stroke of the Angelus he put up the shutters and ate his supper. Then he lit his pipe and strolled to the hall door for a look up and down the Main Street on the off chance of seeing somebody or something. He never did, but it was as well to make sure. Then he returned to the kitchen, his feet beginning to drag as they usually did before he set out for Johnny Desmond’s. It was their way of indicating that they weren’t moving in the right direction. His mother had gone to the chapel and Polly was sitting by the table under the window. Charlie took a deep breath, removed his hands from his pockets, raised his head, and squared his shoulders. “Well,” he said briskly, “I might as well take a little turn.” “Wisha, you might as well, Charlie,” Polly replied without resentment. It was only what she always said, but in Charlie’s state of depression it sounded like a dead key on the piano. He felt it was a hard thing that a married man of a year’s standing had no inclination to stop at home and that his wife had no inclination to make him. Not that she could have made him even if she had tried but he felt that a little persuasion wouldn’t have been out of place. “The mother wasn’t talking to you?” he asked keenly. “No, Charlie,” Polly said in surprise. “What would she talk to me about?” “Oh, nothing in particular. ...Only she was remarking that you were a long time about having a family,” he added with a touch of reproach. “Oh, Law, Charlie,” Polly cried, “wasn’t that a very queer thing for her to say?” “Was it, I wonder?” Charlie said as though to himself but giving her a sideway glance. “But Charlie, you don’t think I won’t have children, do you?” she exclaimed. “Oh, no, no, no,” Charlie replied hastily, in dread he might have said too much. “But ’twould suit her fine if you hadn’t. Then she’d have the place for John Joe’s children.” “But how would John Joe’s children get it?” asked Polly. “Didn’t your father leave it to you?” “To me and my children,” said Charlie. “If I hadn’t children ’twould go to John Joe’s.” “Oh, Law, Charlie, isn’t that a great worry to you?” “Well, it is, a bit,” Charlie conceded, scratching his poll. “I put a lot of work into the place. No one likes working for another man’s family. You wouldn’t see a doctor?” “I’d have to ask Father Ring first.” That upset Charlie again. He nearly told her it was Father Ring she should have married, but remembered in time that she’d be bound to confess it. There’s nothing a good-living woman likes so much as confessing her husband’s sins. V Charlie’s remarks brought Polly for the first time up against the facts of life. This made her very thoughtful, but it was a week before she could even bring herself to discuss it with Nora. It was a subject you could only discuss with a woman, and an intellectual woman at that, and Nora was the only intellectual woman Polly knew. Nora was not inclined to treat it as seriously as Charlie had done. According to her there was a lot of chance in it. Some people went on for years before they had a child; others didn’t even wait for their time to be up. It was quite shocking when you came to think of it, but somehow Polly never did get round to thinking of it. If you were really in trouble, there was always the Holy Door. Johnny Fleming the barrister and his wife had been married ten years without having children, and they had made the pilgrimage to the Holy Door, and now people were beginning to say it was about time they made another to shut off the power. “I suppose I could go next year if I had to,” said Polly doubtfully. “You’ll have to go this year if you’re going at all,” said Nora. “It’s only opened once in seven years.” “Seven years!” cried Polly. “Oh, I could never wait as long as that.” “It would be too dangerous anyway,” said Nora. “There was a woman up our road waited till she was thirty-eight to have a child, and she died.” “Oh, Law!” cried Polly, a little peeved. “I suppose ’tis wrong to be criticizing, but really, the Lord’s ways are very peculiar.” So back she went to Charlie with her story. Charlie screwed up his face as though he were hard of hearing, a favourite trick of his whenever he wanted to gain time. He wanted to gain it now. “Where did you say?” he asked searchingly. “Rome,” repeated Polly. “Rome?” echoed Charlie with a mystified air. “And what did you say you wanted to go to Rome for?” “It’s the pilgrimage to the Holy Door,” said Polly. “You wouldn’t know about that?” she asked in the trustful tone she used to indicate the respect she had for his learning. “No,” replied Charlie doubtfully, playing up to the part of the well-informed husband. “What sort of door?” “A holy door.” “A holy door?” “’Tis only opened once in seven years, and ’tis good for people that want families,” prompted Polly hopefully. “Is that so?” asked Charlie gravely. “Who told you about that?” “Nora Lawlor.” “Tut, tut, tut,” clucked Charlie impatiently, “ah, I wouldn’t say there would be any truth in that, Polly.” “Oh, Law, Charlie,” she cried in ringing tones, outraged at his lack of faith, “you surely don’t think the Flemings would go all that way unless there was something in it?” “Oh, no, no, no, I dare say not,” Charlie said hastily, seeing that any further objections he made were likely to be reported back to Father Ring. “I’m afraid I couldn’t get away, though.” “Well, I’ll have to get away, Charlie,” Polly said with quiet decision. “It might be too late if I left it for another seven years. Nora says ’tis very dangerous.” “And a hell of a lot of danger that one will ever be in!” snapped Charlie fierily. His bad temper did not last long. This was an excuse for an outing, and Charlie loved an outing. He had never been farther than London before; Paris staggered him; he experimented with green drinks, pink drinks, and yellow drinks with the satisfied expression of a child in a pantry; and while the train passed through the Alps in the late evening he wedged himself in the corridor with his elbows on the rail, humming “Home to Our Mountains,” while tears of excitement poured down his hairy cheeks. He couldn’t forget that he was going to the homeland of Romeo and Juliet. He quickly made friends with the other two occupants of the carriage, a fat Dutchman in shirtsleeves who ate sausqages and embraced the woman beside him who he said was his wife. The sight was too gross for Polly and she went and stood in the corridor but not to look at the scenery. “Isn’t she beautiful?” said the Dutchman, stroking his companion affectionately under the chin. “Grand! grand!” agreed Charlie enthusiastically, nodding and smiling encouragement to the woman, who couldn’t speak English and to all appearances didn’t know much of any other language either. That’s a nice-looking girl with you ,’ said the Dutchman. “Who is she?” “Polly?” said Charlie looking at the gloomy figure in the corridor. “Oh, that’s the wife.” “Whose wife?” asked the Dutchman. “Mine,” said Charlie. “And don’t you love her?” “Love her?” echoed Charlie, giving another peep out. “I’m cracked on her, of course.” “Then why don’t you make love to her?” asked the Dutchman in surprise. “Women can’t have enough of it. Look at this!” “Ah, mine wouldn’t like it,” said Charlie in alarm. “In Ireland we don’t go in much for that sort of thing.” “And what do you go in for?” “Well,” says Charlie doubtfully, seeing that he didn’t quite know himself—apart from politics, which didn’t sound right—“we’re more in the sporting line; horses and dogs, you know.” “Ah,” said the Dutchman earnestly, “you can’t beat women.” Charlie went out to Polly, who was leaning with her back to the compartment and a brooding look on her face. “Charlie, how do they do it?” she asked in a troubled voice. “Wouldn’t you think the woman would drop dead with shame? I suppose they’re Protestants, are they, Charlie?” “I dare say, I dare say,” said Charlie, thinking it was better not to try to explain. VI It was a great outing and it lasted Charlie in small talk for a month. The grapes like gooseberries, and from nightfall on every little café with soprano or tenor or baritone bawling away about love—_amore, mio cuore, traditore_—you could see where Juliet got it. But they weren’t there long enough for Polly to be infected, and all the wonders she brought back was her astonishment at the way the men in St. Peter’s pinched her bottom. “Your what, Polly?” the neighbours asked in surprise. “My bottom,” repeated Polly incredulously. “Would you believe it?” After that, Morgan, the wit of Johnny Desmond’s pub, began dropping nasty remarks about doors of one sort and another, while old Mrs. Cashman, getting over her alarm at the possibility of divine intervention, declared loudly that it would be a poor lookout for a woman like her to be relying on a son who had to take his wife to Rome. It didn’t take a miracle to start John Joe’s wife off, for the poor wretch had only to look at her. But Polly, to give her her due, was every bit as upset as Charlie. Sixty pounds odd the pilgrimage had cost, and they had absolutely nothing to show for it. If the Holy Door couldn’t do a thing like that it couldn’t be so holy after all. She scolded Nora Lawlor a lot over her bad advice. “But after all, Polly,” Nora said reasonably, “you mustn’t expect too much. It might be something mental.” “Oh, how could it, Nora?” Polly cried in a fury. “What a thing to say!” “But why not?” asked Nora with a touch of asperity. “If you didn’t feel attracted to Charlie—” “Oh,” said Polly vaguely and guardedly but with a dim comprehension dawning in her eyes, “would that make a difference?” “It might make all the difference in the world, Polly,” Nora said severely. “After all, there was Kitty Daly. She was married eight years without having a family, and one night she pretended to herself that her husband was Rudolph Valentino, and everything was all right.” “Rudolph Valentino?” said Polly. “Who’s he?” “He was a film actor,” said Nora. “But why would she do that?” “Well, I suppose he was a nice-looking man, and you know what sort Jerome Daly is.” “Would there be a picture of that fellow that I could see?” asked Polly. “I wouldn’t say so,” replied Nora. “Anyway, he’s dead now, so I suppose it wouldn’t be right. But, of course, there are plenty of others just as nice-looking.” “Oh, I don’t think it could ever be right,” cried Polly with a petulant toss of her head. She was feeling very sorry for herself. She knew quite well that that sly thing, Nora, was trying to worm out of her what Charlie really did to her and she was torn asunder between the need for revealing something and the desire not to reveal anything at all. “I’m sure Father Ring would say it was wrong.” “I don’t see why he would,” Nora said coolly. “After all, it was done with a good purpose.” Polly had no reply to that, for she knew the importance of doing things with a good purpose, but at the same time the temptation lingered. The following Saturday evening she went to confession to Father Ring. Her sins didn’t take long to tell. They were never what you’d call major ones. “Father,” she said when she had done, “I want to ask your advice.” “What about, my child?” asked Father Ring. “It’s my husband, father,” said Polly. “You see, we have no children, and I know it’s a terrible worry to him, so I went on the pilgrimage to the Holy Door but it didn’t do me any good.” “Go on,” said Father Ring. “So a friend of mine was telling me about another woman that was in the same position. It seems she imagined her husband was Rudolph Valentino.” “Who was he?” “Some sort of fellow on the pictures.” “But what made her think he was her husband?” asked Father Ring with a puzzled frown. “Oh, she didn’t think it,” said Polly in distress. “She only pretended. It seems he was a very nice-looking fellow and her husband is an insignificant little man. ... Of course, I could understand that,” she added candidly. “My husband is a very good fellow, but somehow he doesn’t look right.” “Is it Charlie?” exclaimed Father Ring, so astonished that he broke the tone of decent anonymity in which the discussion was being conducted. “Sure, Charlie is a grand-looking man.” “Oh, would you think so?” asked Polly with real interest. “Of course I might be wrong. But anyway, this woman had a child after.” “What did she call him?” asked Father Ring. “I don’t know, father. Why? Does it make any difference?” “No. I was just wondering.” “But tell me, father, would that ever be right?” asked Polly. “Ah, I don’t say there would be anything wrong about it,” said Father Ring, pulling aside the curtain before the confessional and peeping out into the darkened church. “Of course she did it with a good object.” “That’s what my friend said,” said Polly, amazed at the intellect of that little gligeen of a girl. “Provided, of course, she didn’t get any pleasure from it,” Father Ring added hastily. “If she got carnal pleasure out of it that would be a different thing.” “Oh!” exclaimed Polly, aghast. “You don’t think she’d do that?” “What I mean,” the priest explained patiently, “is more than the natural pleasure.” “The natural pleasure?” repeated Polly with a stunned air. “However,” said Father Ring hastily, “I don’t think you’re in much danger of that.” It was shortly after this that Charlie began to notice a change in the atmosphere in Johnny Desmond’s. Charlie was very sensitive to atmosphere. First Morgan passed a remark about Polly and the new teacher, Carmody. Now, Carmody was a relative of Father Ring’s, as has been said, a good-looking plausible Kerryman who put on great airs with the women. Charlie greeted the remark with a sniff and a laugh and was almost on the point of telling how Polly wouldn’t let him switch on the light while she dressed for Mass. Then he began to wonder. The remark had stuck. The next time Polly’s name was mentioned in connection with Carmody he scowled. It was clear that something was going on and that he was the victim. He couldn’t bear the thought of that. It might be that in her innocence Polly was being indiscreet. On the other hand it might well be that like many another woman before her, she was only letting on to be innocent to get the chance of being indiscreet. A man could never tell. He went home feeling very upset. He strode in the hall and snapped a command to Polly, who was sitting in the darkness over the range. She rose in surprise and followed him meekly up the stairs. In the sitting-room he lit the gas and stooped to look up under the mantel as though to see if the burner was broken. Like all worriers Charlie considered nothing beneath him. “Sit down,” he said curtly over his shoulder. “Oh, Law, what is it at all, Charlie?” Polly asked nervously. Charlie turned and stood on the hearthrug, his legs apart like buttresses, his cap drawn down over his eyes, and seemed as if he were studying her through his hairy cheekbones. It was a matter that required study. He had no precedent for inquiring whether or not Polly had been unfaithful to him. “Tell me, Polly,” he said at last in a reasonable tone which seemed to suit the part, “did I do anything to you?” “Oh, whatever do you mean, Charlie?” she asked in bewilderment. “What could you do to me?” “That’s just what I’d like to know,” said Charlie, nodding sagaciously. “What I did out of the way.” “Oh, Charlie,” she exclaimed in alarm, “what a thing to say to me! I never said you did anything out of the way.” “I’m glad to hear it,” said Charlie, nodding again and looking away across the room at the picture of a sailing-ship in distress, “I suppose you don’t know the new teacher in the school?” he added with the innocent air of a cross-examining lawyer. “Is it Mr. Carmody?” she asked, giving herself away at once by the suspicion of a blush. “Aha, I see you do,” said Charlie. “I met him a couple of times with Mrs. MacCann,” Polly explained patiently. “What about him?” “Now is that all?” Charlie asked accusingly. “You might as well tell me the truth now and not have me drag it out of you.” “Oh, what do you mean?” cried Polly, sitting erect with indignation. “What would you drag out of me? I don’t know what’s coming over you at all, Charlie.” “Hold on now, hold on!” Charlie said commandingly, raising one hand for silence. “Just sit where you are for a minute.” He put his hands behind his back, tilted forward on his toes and studied his feet for a moment. “Do you know,” he added gravely, barely raising his head to fix her with his eyes, “that ’tis all over the town that you and Carmody are carrying on behind my back? Isn’t that a nice thing to have said about your wife?” he added, raising his voice. Up to that moment he had only partly believed in her guilt, but he no longer had any doubt when he saw how she changed colour. It was partly anger, partly shame. “Oh,” she cried in a fury, tossing her handsome black head, “the badness of people! This is all Nora Lawlor’s fault. Father Ring would never repeat a thing like that.” “Father Ring?” exclaimed Charlie with a start, seeing that, whatever her crime was, it was already public property. “What has he to do with it?” “I see it all now,” Polly cried dramatically with a large wave of her arm. “I should never have trusted her. I might have known she’d bell it all over the town.” “What would she bell?” snapped Charlie impatiently. At the very best of times Polly was not what you’d call lucid, but whenever anything happened to upset her, every joint in her mind flew asunder. “She said,” explained Polly earnestly, wagging a long arm at him, “that Kitty Daly had a child after imagining her husband was Rudolph Valentino.” “Rudolph who?” asked Charlie with a strained air. “You wouldn’t know him,” replied Polly impatiently. “He’s an old fellow on the pictures. He’s dead now.” “And what has he to do with Carmody?” Charlie asked anxiously. “He has nothing to do with Carmody,” shouted Polly, enraged at his stupidity. “Well, go on, woman, go on!” said Charlie, his face screwed up in a black knot as he tried to disentangle the confusion she had plunged him in. “Oh, I know it couldn’t be wrong, Charlie,” Polly said positively, flying off at another tangent. “I asked Father Ring myself was it wrong for her.” “Wrong for who?” snarled Charlie, beside himself. “Kitty Daly, of course,” shouted Polly. “Christ Almighty!” groaned Charlie. “Do you want to drive me mad?” “But when you won’t listen to me!” Polly cried passionately. “And Father Ring said there was no harm in it so long as she was doing it for a good purpose and didn’t get any pleasure out of it. ...Though indeed,” she added candidly, “I’m sure I have no idea what pleasure she could get out of it.” “Ah, botheration!” shouted Charlie, shaking his fists at her. “What goings-on you have about Rudolph Valentino! Don’t you see I’m demented with all this hugger-mugger? What did you do then, woman?” “I went to the pictures,” replied Polly with an aggrieved air. “You went to the pictures with Carmody?” asked Charlie encouragingly, only too willing to compound for an infidelity with an indiscretion. “Oh, what a thing I’d do!” cried Polly in a perfect tempest of indignation. “Who said I went to the pictures with Mr. Carmody? This town is full of liars. I went with Nora, of course.” “Well?” asked Charlie. “Well,” Polly continued in a more reasonable tone, “I thought all the old men in the pictures were terrible, Charlie. How people can bear the sight of them night after night I do not know. And as we were coming out Nora asked me wasn’t there any man at all I thought was good-looking, and I said: ‘Nora,’ I said, ‘I always liked Mr. Carmody’s appearance.’ ‘Oh, did you?’ said Nora. ‘I did, Nora,’ said I. “Now that,” said Polly flatly, bringing her palm down on her knee, “was all that either of us said; and, of course, I might be wrong about his appearance, though I always thought he kept himself very nicely; but anyone that says I went to the pictures with him, Charlie, all I can say is that they have no conscience. Absolutely no conscience.” Charlie stared at her for a moment in stupefaction. For that one moment he wondered at his own folly in ever thinking that Polly would have it in her to carry on with a man and in thinking that any man would try to carry on with her. _Amore, mio cuore, traditore_, he thought despairingly. Quite clearly Italian women must be different. And then the whole thing began to dawn on him and he felt himself suffocating with rage. “And do you mean to tell me,” he asked incredulously, “that you went to Father Ring and asked him could you pretend that I was Charlie Carmody?” “Rudolph Valentino, Charlie,” corrected Polly. “It was Nora Lawlor who suggested Mr. Carmody. ...You don’t think it makes any difference?” she added hastily, terrified that she might unwittingly have drifted into mortal sin. “You asked Father Ring could you pretend that I was Rudolph Valentino?” repeated Charlie frantically. “Oh, surely Charlie,” Polly said, brushing this aside as mere trifling, “you don’t think I’d do it without finding out whether ’twas a sin or not?” “God Almighty!” cried Charlie, turning to the door. “I’m the laughing-stock of the town!” “Oh, you think too much about what people say of you,” Polly said impatiently. “What need you care what they say so long as ’tis for a good object?” “Good object!” cried Charlie bitterly. “I know the object I’d like to lay my hands on this minute. It’s that Nora Lawlor with her cesspool of a mind. By God, I’d wring her bloody neck!” VII That was nothing to what Nora did later. Somebody, Charlie discovered, had put round the story that it was really his fault and not Polly’s that they had no children. Of course, that might well have been a misconception of Polly’s own, because he learned from a few words she dropped that she thought his mother was a witch and was putting spells on her. A girl who would believe that was quite capable of blaming it on the butcher’s boy. But the obvious malice identified the story as Nora’s. The Carmody business was only a flea-bite to it, because it lowered him in the estimation of everybody. Morgan made great play with it. And it was clever because Charlie was in no position to prove it a lie. Worst of all, he doubted himself. He was a nervous man; the least thing set him off; and for weeks and weeks he worried till he almost convinced himself that Nora was right, that he wasn’t like other men. God had heaped so many burdens on him that this was all he could expect. Now, the Cashmans had a maid called Molly O’Regan, a country girl with a rosy, laughing, good-natured face and a shrill penetrating voice. She was one of the few people Charlie knew who were not afraid of his mother, and in his bachelor days when she brought him his shaving-water of a morning, she had always leaned in the door and shown him just enough of herself to interest a half-wakened man. “Come in, girl,” he would whisper, “come in and shut the door.” “What would I come in for?” Molly would ask with a great air of surprise. “’Pon my soul,” Charlie would say admiringly, “you’re most captivating.” “Captivating?” Molly would shriek. “Listen to him, you sweet God! There’s capers for you!” “You’re like a rose,” Charlie would say and then give one wild bound out of the bed that landed him within a few feet of her, while Molly, shrieking with laughter, banged the door behind her. It was undoubtedly the slander on his manhood which interested Charlie in Molly, though it would be going too far to say that he had no other object than to disprove it. He liked Molly, and more than ever with Polly and his mother round the house she seemed like a rose. Sometimes when they were out he followed her upstairs and skirmished with her. She let on to be very shocked. “Sweet Jesus!” she cried, “What would I do if one of them walked in on me? And all the holy pictures!” She flashed a wondering look at all the coloured pictures, the statues, and the Lourdes clock. “Isn’t it true for me?” she cried. “A wonder you wouldn’t have a bit of shame in you!” “As a matter of fact,” said Charlie gravely, “that’s the idea. You knew I was starting a religious order of my own here, didn’t your” “A religious order?” echoed Molly. “I did not.” “Oh, yes, yes,” said Charlie importantly. “I’m only waiting on the authority from Rome.” “What sort of religious order?” asked Molly suspiciously—she was not too bright in the head and, as she said herself, with that thundering blackguard, Charlie Cashman, you’d never know where you were. “An order of Christian married couples,” replied Charlie. “The old sort of marriage is a washout. Purity is what we’re going in for.” “Purity?” shrieked Molly in a gale of laughter. “And you in it!” Secretly she was delighted to see Charlie among all “them old holy ones,” as she called them, showing such spunk, and couldn’t bear to deprive him of his little pleasure. She didn’t deprive him of it long. And then one autumn evening she whispered to him that she was going to have a baby. She wept and said her old fellow would have her sacred life, which was likely enough, seeing that her father preferred to correct his large family with a razor. Charlie shed a few tears as well and told her not to mind her old fellow; while he had a pound in the bank he’d never see her short of anything. He meant it too, because he was a warm-hearted man and had always kept a soft spot for Molly. But what really moved and thrilled him was that in spite of everybody he was at last going to be a father. His doubts about his manhood were set at rest. In the dusk he went up to Johnny Desmond’s overflowing with delight and good humour. He cracked half a dozen jokes at Morgan in quick succession and made them all wonder what he had up his sleeve. From this out they could pass what dirty remarks they liked, but these would be nothing compared with his secret laugh at them. It didn’t matter if it took twenty years before they knew. He was in the wildest spirits, drinking and joking and making up rhymes. Next morning, coming on to dawn, he woke with a very bad taste in his mouth. He glanced round and there, in the light of the colza-oil lamp that burned before the statue of the Sacred Heart, saw Polly beside him in the bed. She looked determined even in sleep. The Lourdes clock, which was suffering from hallucinations and imagining it was an alarm clock, was kicking up merry hell on the mantelpiece. He knew it was really playing “The bell of the Angelus calleth to pray,” which is a nice, soothing, poetic thought, but what it said in his mind was: “You’re caught, Charlie Cashman, you can’t get away.” He realized that, instead of escaping, he had only wedged himself more firmly in the trap, that if ever the truth about Molly became known, Polly would leave him, the Donegans would hound him down, Father Ring would denounce him from the altar, and his little business would go to pot. And in spite of it all he would not be able to leave the business to his son. “You’re caught, Charlie Cashman, you can’t get away,” sang the clock with a sort of childish malice. The skill with which he manoeuvred Molly out of the house would have done credit to an international statesman. He found her lodgings in Asragh and put some money to her name in the bank without anyone being the wiser. But in crises it is never the difficulties you can calculate on that really upset you. How could anyone have guessed that Molly, without a job to do, would find her time a burden and spend hours in the Redemptorist church? After a couple of months Charlie started to receive the most alarming letters. Molly talked of telling Polly, of telling her father, of spending the rest of her days in a home doing penance. Charlie was getting thoroughly fed up with religion. When he saw her one night in a back street in Asragh—the only place where they could meet in comparative safety—he was shocked at the change in her. She was plumper and better-looking but her eyes were shadowy and her voice had dropped to a sort of whine. “Oh, Charlie,” she sighed with a lingering, come-to-Christ air, “what luck or grace could we have and the life of sin and deception we’re leading?” “A lot of deception and damn little sin,” Charlie said bitterly. “What the hell do you want?”. “Oh, Charlie, I want you to put an end to the deception as well as the sin. Be said by me and confess it to your wife.” “What a thing I’d do!” Charlie said, scowling and stamping. “Do you know what she’d do?” “What would any woman do and she finding you truly repentant?” asked Molly ecstatically. “She’d take bloody good care I had cause,” said Charlie. He persuaded her out of that particular mood but all the same he wasn’t sure of her. It was a nerve-racking business. In the evenings after his supper he lit his pipe and took his usual prowl to the door but he couldn’t bring himself to leave the house. Nora Lawlor might drop in while he was away and tell the whole thing to Polly. He had a trick of making up little rhymes to amuse himself, and one that he made at this time ran: _Brass, boys, brass, and not only buttons, The older we gets, the more we toughens._ Charlie didn’t toughen at all, unfortunately. “Wisha, wouldn’t you go for a little stroll?” Polly would ask considerately. “Ah, I don’t feel like it,” Charlie would say with a sigh. “Oh, Law!” she would cry in gentle surprise. “Isn’t that a great change for you, Charlie?” Once or twice he nearly snapped at her and asked whose fault it was. Sometimes he went to the house door and stood there for a full half-hour with his shoulder against the jamb, drinking in the misery of the view in the winter dusk: the one mean main street where everyone knew him and no one wished him well. It was all very fine for Romeo, but Romeo hadn’t to live in an Irish country town. Each morning he prowled about in wait for Christy Flynn, the postman, to intercept any anonymous letter there might be for Polly. As he didn’t know which of them were anonymous, he intercepted them all. Then one morning the blow fell. It was a solicitor’s letter. He left the shop in charge of Polly and went down to Curwen Street to see his own solicitor, Timsy Harrington. Curwen Street is a nice quiet Georgian street, rosy and warm even on a winter’s day, and signs on it; the cheapest call you could pay there would cost you a pound. Charlie knew his call would cost him more than that, but he smoked his pipe and tried to put a brave face on it, as though he thought actions for seduction the best sport in the world. That didn’t go down with Timsy Harrington, though. “Mr. Cashman,” he said in his shrill, scolding, old woman’s voice, “I’m surprised at you. I’m astonished at you. An educated man like you! You had the whole country to choose from and no one would do you but a daughter of Jim Regan, that stopped in bed with his son for eight months, hoping to get a couple of pounds out of the insurance company.” Charlie went back along the main street feeling as though he were bleeding from twenty gashes. He swore that if ever he got out of this scrape he’d live a celibate for the rest of his days. People said the woman always paid, but the particular occasion when she did was apparently forgotten. Outside the shop he was accosted by an old countryman with a long innocent face. “Good morrow, Charlie,” he said confidentially, giving Charlie a glimpse of a plug in the palm of his hand. “I wonder would you have the comrade of this?” “I’ll try, Tom,” said Charlie with a sigh, taking it from him and turning it over in his hand. “Leave me this and I’ll see what I can do. I’m very busy at the moment.” He opened the shop door, and knew at once that there was trouble in the wind. There was no one in the shop. He stood at the door with his ear cocked. He heard Polly moving with stallion strides about the bedroom and his heart misgave him. He knew well the Lawlor one had profited by his absence. Already the solicitor’s letter was public property. He went up the stairs and opened the bedroom door a few inches. Polly was throwing clothes, shoes, and statues all together in a couple of suitcases with positive frenzy. Charlie pushed in the door a little further, looked at the suitcases, then at her, and finally managed to work up what he thought of as an insinuating smile. “What’s up, little girl?” he asked with a decent show of innocent gaiety. He saw from her look that this particular line was a complete washout, so he entered cautiously, closing the door behind him for fear of being overheard from the shop. “Aren’t I in trouble enough?” he asked bitterly. “Do you know what the O’Regans want out of me?” “Oh,” cried Polly with the air of a tragedy queen, “if there was a man among them he’d shoot you!” “Two hundred pounds!” hissed Charlie, his high hairy cheekbones twitching. “Isn’t that a nice how-d’ye-do?” “Oh,” she cried distractedly, “you’re worse than the wild beasts. The wild beasts have some modesty but you have none. It was my own fault. Nora Lawlor warned me.” “Nora Lawlor will be the ruination of you,” Charlie said severely. “She was in here again this morning—you needn’t tell me. I can see the signs of her.” “Don’t attempt to criticize her to me!” stormed Polly. “Get out of my sight or I won’t be responsible. The servant!” “Whisht, woman, whisht, whisht, whisht!” hissed Charlie, dancing in a fury of apprehension. “You’ll be heard from the shop.” “Oh, I’ll take care to be heard,” said Polly, giving her rich voice full play. “I’ll let them know the sort of man they’re dealing with. I’ll soho you well.” “So this is married life!” muttered Charlie in a wounded voice, turning away. Then he paused and looked at her over his shoulder as if he couldn’t believe it. “Merciful God,” he said, “what sort of woman are you at all? How well I didn’t go on like this about the schoolmaster!” “What schoolmaster?” Polly asked in bewilderment, her whole face taking on a ravaged air. “Carmody,” said Charlie reproachfully. “You thought it was my fault and I thought it was yours—what more was in it? We both acted with a good purpose. Surely to God,” he added anxiously, “you don’t think I did it for pleasure?” “Oh,” she cried, beside herself, “wait till I tell Father Ring! Wait till he knows the sort of comparisons you’re making! With a good purpose! Oh, you blasphemer! How the earth doesn’t open and swallow you!” She pushed him out and slammed the door behind him. Charlie stood on the landing and gave a brokenhearted sigh. “So this is married life!” he repeated despairingly. He returned to the shop and stood far back at the rear, leaning against the stovepipe. It was a sunny morning and the sunlight streamed through the windows and glinted on the bright buckets hanging outside the door. He saw Nora Lawlor, wearing a scarlet coat, come out of the butcher’s and give a furtive glance across the street. If he had had a gun with him he would have shot her dead. He heard Polly come downstairs and open the hall door. Slowly and on tiptoe he went to the door of the shop, leaned his shoulder against the jamb and looked up the street after Nora. He saw her red coat disappear round the corner by the chapel. The old farmer who was waiting outside the Post Office thought that Charlie was hailing him, but Charlie frowned and shook his head. From the hall he heard Polly address a small boy in that clear voice of hers which he knew could be heard all along the street. “Dinny,” she said, “I want you to run down to Hennessey’s and ask them to send up a car.” Charlie was so overcome that he retreated to the back of the shop again. Polly was leaving him. It would be all round the town in five minutes. Yet he knew he wasn’t a bad man; there were plenty worse and their wives didn’t leave them. For one wild moment he thought of making a last appeal to her love, but one glance into the hall at Polly sitting bolt-upright in her blue serge costume, her cases beside her and her gloves and prayerbook on the hall stand, and he knew that love wasn’t even in the running. He went to the shop door and beckoned to another small boy. “I want you to find Father Ring and bring him here quick,” he whispered fiercely, pressing a coin into the child’s palm. “Mr. Cashman sent you, say. And tell him hurry!” “Is it someone sick, Mr. Cashman?” asked the little boy eagerly. “Yes,” hissed Charlie. “Dying. Hurry now!” After that he paced up and down the shop like a caged tiger till he saw Father Ring rounding the corner by the chapel. He went up to meet him. “What is it at all, Charlie?” the priest asked anxiously. “Is it ‘the mother?” “No, father,” Charlie said desperately, seeing the twitching of curtains in top rooms. “I only wish to God it was,” he ground out in a frenzy. “Is it as bad as that, Charlie?” Father Ring asked in concern as they entered the shop. “Ah, I’m in great trouble, father,” Charlie said, tossing his head like a wounded animal. Then he fixed his gaze on a spot of light at the back of the shop and addressed himself to it. “I don’t know did you hear any stories about me,” he inquired guardedly. “Stories, Charlie?” exclaimed Father Ring, who, being a Kerryman, could fight a better delaying-action than Charlie himself. “What sort of stories?” “Well, now, father, not the sort you’d like to hear,” replied Charlie with what for him was almost candour. “Well, now you mention it, Charlie,” said Father Ring with equal frankness, “I fancy I did hear something. ... Not, of course, that I believed it,” he added hastily, for fear he might be committing himself too far. “I’m sorry to say you can, father,” said Charlie, bowing his head and joining his hands before him as he did at Mass on Sunday. “Oh, my, my, Charlie,” said Father Ring, giving him a look out of the corner of his eye, “that’s bad.” Charlie looked at the floor and nodded glumly a couple of times to show he shared the priest’s view of it. “And tell me, Charlie,” whispered Father Ring, pivoting on his umbrella as he leaned closer, “what way did herself take it?” “Badly, father,” replied Charlie severely. “Very badly. I must say I’m disappointed in Polly.” This time it was he who looked out of the corner of his eye and somehow it struck him that Father Ring was not as shocked-looking as he might have been. “I’d expect that, mind you,” Father Ring said thoughtfully. “By God, he isn’t shocked!” thought Charlie. There was something that almost resembled fellow-feeling in his air. “But heavens above, father,” Charlie said explosively, “the woman is out of her mind. And as for that Lawlor girl, I don’t know what to say to her.” Father Ring nodded again, as though to say that he didn’t know either. “Of course, she’s a good-living girl and all the rest of it,” Charlie went on cantankerously, “but girls with no experience of life have no business interfering between married couples. It was bad enough without her—I needn’t tell you that. And there she is now,” he added, cocking his thumb in the direction of the hall, “with her bags packed and after ordering a car up from Hennessey’s. Sure that’s never right.” “Well, now, Charlie,” Father Ring whispered consolingly, “women are contrairy; they are contrairy, there’s no denying that. I’ll have a word with her myself.” He opened the house door gently, peeped in, and then went into the hall on tiptoe, as if he were entering a room where someone was asleep. Charlie held the door slightly open behind him to hear what went on. Unfortunately, the sight of the priest going in had given the old farmer the notion of business as usual. Charlie looked round and saw his long mournful face in the doorway. “Charlie,” he began, “if I’m not disturbing you—” Charlie, raising his clenched fists in the air, did a silent war dance. The old farmer staggered back, cut to the heart, and then sat on the sill of the window with his stick between his legs. When another farmer came by the old man began to tell him his troubles with long, accusing glances back at Charlie, who was glued to the door with an agonized look on his face. “My poor child!” he heard Father Ring say in a shocked whisper. “You were in the wars. I can see you were.” “Well, I’m going home now, father,” Polly replied listlessly. “Sure, where better could you go?” exclaimed Father Ring as if trying to disabuse her of any idea she might have of staying on. “’Tis that husband of yours, I suppose? ’Tis to be sure. I need hardly ask.” “I’d rather not talk about it, father,” Polly said politely but firmly. “I dare say you’ll hear all about it soon enough.” “I dare say I will,” he agreed. “People in this town don’t seem to have much better to do. ’Pon my word, I believe I saw a few curtains stirring on my way down. You’ll have an audience.” “I never minded much what they saw,” said Polly wearily. “Sure, you never had anything to conceal,” said Father Ring, overwhelming her with agreement, as his way was. “I suppose you remember the case of that little girl from Parnell Street a few weeks ago?” “No, father, I’m afraid I don’t,” replied Polly without interest. “Sure, you. couldn’t be bothered. Ah, ’twas a sad business, though. Married at ten and the baby born at one.” “Oh, my, father,” said Polly politely, “wasn’t that very quick?” “Well, now you mention it, Polly, it was. But that wasn’t what I was going to say. The poor child came home at four in the morning to avoid attracting attention, and would you believe me, Polly, not a soul in Parnell Street went to bed that night! Sure, that’s never natural! I say that’s not natural. Where’s that blackguard of a husband of yours till I give him a bit of my mind? Charlie Cashman! Charlie Cashman! Where are you, you scoundrel?” “I’m here, father,” said Charlie meekly, taking two steps forward till he stood between the crimson curtains with a blaze of silver from the fanlight falling on his bowed head. “Aren’t you ashamed of yourself£?” shouted the priest, raising the umbrella to him. “I am, father, I am, I am,” replied Charlie in a broken voice without looking up. “Oh, that’s only all old connoisseuring, father,” Polly cried distractedly, jumping to her feet and grabbing gloves and prayerbook. “No one knows what I went through with that man.” She opened the hall door; the hall was flooded with silver light, and she turned to them, drawing a deep breath through her nose, as beautiful and menacing as a sibyl. “I’m going home to my father now,” she continued in a firm voice. “I left my keys on the dressing-table and you can give Hennessey’s boy the bags.” “Polly,” Father Ring said sternly, leaning on his umbrella, “what way is this for a Child of Mary to behave?” “As, ’tis all very fine for you to talk, father,” Polly cried scoldingly. “You don’t have to live with him. I’d sooner live with a wild beast than with that man,” she added dramatically. “Polly,” Father Ring said mildly, “what you do in your own house is your business. What you do in the public view is mine. Polly, you’re in the public view.” For the first time in Charlie’s life he found himself admiring Father Ring. There was a clash and a grating of wills like the bending of steel girders, and suddenly Polly’s girders buckled. She came in and closed the door. “Now, Polly,” Father Ring said affectionately, “inside that door I don’t want to interfere between ye, good or bad. Make what arrangements you like. Live with him or don’t live with him; sleep in the loft or sleep in the stable, but don’t let me have any more scandal like we had this morning.” “I wouldn’t be safe from him in the stable,” Polly said rebelliously. She felt that for the first time in her life she had been met and mastered by a man, and it rankled. There was more than a joke in Charlie’s suggestion that it was Father Ring she should have married. If only she could have gone to bed with him then and there she would probably have risen a normal woman. But deprived of this consolation she was ready to turn nasty, and Father Ring saw it. Charlie only noticed the falsehood about himself. “You wouldn’t be what?” he cried indignantly. “When did I ever raise a finger or say a cross word to you?” “Now, Charlie, now!” Father Ring said shortly, raising his hand for silence. “And woman alive,” he asked good-humouredly, “can’t you bolt your door?” “How can I,” stormed Polly, as sulky as a spoiled child, “when there’s no bolt on it?” “That’s easily remedied.” “Then tell him send out for a carpenter and have it done now,” she said vindictively. “Send out for a what?” shouted Charlie, cocking his head as if he couldn’t believe what he heard. “Is it mad you are? What a thing I’d do!” “Very well,” she said, opening the hall door again. “I’ll go home to my father.” “Hold on now, hold on!” Charlie cried frantically, dragging her back and closing the door behind her. “I’ll do it myself.” “Then do it now!” she cried. “Do what she says, Charlie,” the priest said quietly. He saw that the danger wasn’t over yet. Charlie gave her a murderous glare and went out to the shop. A crowd had gathered outside on the pavement, discussing the wrongs of the poor farmer, who was an object of the most intense sympathy. Charlie returned with a brass bolt, a screwdriver, and a couple of screws. “Show me that bolt!” said Polly menacingly. The devil was up in her now. The priest might have bested her but she still saw a way of getting her own back. Charlie knew that next day she and Nora Lawlor would be splitting their sides over it; women were like that, and he vowed a holy war against the whole boiling of them to the day of his death. “I’m going home to my father’s,” she said, clamping her long lips. “That bolt is too light.” “Get a heavier one, Charlie,” Father Ring said quietly. “Don’t argue, there’s a good man!” Argument was about the last thing in Charlie’s mind at that moment. Murder would have been nearer the mark. He flung the bolt at Polly’s feet but she didn’t even glance at him. When he returned to the shop the crowd was surging round the door. “Bad luck and end to ye!” he snarled, taking out his spleen on them. “Have ye no business of yeer own to mind without nosing round here?” “Mr. Cashman,” said a young man whom Charlie recognized as the old farmer’s son, “you have a plug belonging to my father.” “Then take it and to hell with ye!” snarled Charlie, taking the plug from his pocket and throwing it into the midst of them. “Oh, begor, we won’t trouble you much from this day forth,” the young man said fierily. “Nor more along with us.” That was the trouble in a quarrel with a country man. There always were more along with him. Charlie, aware that he might have seriously injured his business, returned to the hall with an iron bolt. “That’s a stable bolt,” he said, addressing no one in particular. “Put it on,” said Polly. Charlie went upstairs. Father Ring followed him. The priest stood in awe, looking at all the holy pictures. Then he held the bolt while Charlie used the screwdriver. Charlie was so mad that he used it anyhow. You’re putting that screw in crooked, Charlie,” said the priest. “Wait now till I put on my specs and I’ll do it for you.” “Let her go! Let her go!” said Charlie on the point of a breakdown. “It doesn’t matter to me whether she goes or stays. I’m nothing only a laughing-stock.” “Now, Charlie, Charlie,” said the priest good-naturedly, “you have your little business to mind.” “For my nephews to walk into,” said Charlie bitterly. “God spoke first, Charlie,” the priest said gravely. “You’re a young man yet. Begor,” he added, giving Charlie a quizzical look over the specs, “I did a few queer jobs in my time but this is the queerest yet.” He saw that Charlie was in no state to appreciate the humour of it, and gave him a professional look through the spectacles. “Ah, well, Charlie,” he said, “we all have our burdens. You have only one, but I have a dozen, not to mention the nuns, and they reckon two on a count.” As they came down the stairs Charlie’s mother appeared out of the kitchen as if from nowhere, drying her hands in her apron; a little bundle of rags, bones and malice, with a few wisps of white hair blowing about her. “Aha,” she cackled as if she were speaking to herself, “I hear the Holy Door is shut for the next seven years.” VIII But, as she was so fond of saying herself, “God spoke first.” It seemed as if Polly never had another day’s luck. She fell into a slow decline and made herself worse instead of better by drinking the stuff Mrs. Cashman brought her from the Wise Woman, and by changing from the Nine Fridays to the Nine Tuesdays and from the Nine Tuesdays to the Nine Mondays on the advice of Nora Lawlor, who had tried them all. A scandal of that sort is never good for a man’s business. The Donegans and their friends paid their accounts and went elsewhere. The shop began to go down and Charlie went with it. He paid less attention to his appearance, served the counter unshaven and without collar and tie; grew steadily shabbier and more irritable and neglected-looking. He spent most of his evenings in Johnny Desmond’s, but even there people fought shy of him. The professional men and civil servants treated him as a sort of town character, a humorous, unreliable fellow without much balance. To Charlie, who felt they were only cashing in on the sacrifices of men like himself, this was the bitterest blow, and in his anxiety to keep his end up before them he boasted, quarrelled, and generally played the fool. But the funny thing was that from the time she fell ill Polly herself softened towards him. Her family were the first to notice it. Like everything else in Polly it went to extremes, and indeed it occurred to her mother that if the Almighty God in His infinite mercy didn’t release her soon, she’d have no religion left. “I don’t know is he much worse than anyone else,” she said broodingly. “I had some very queer temptations myself that no one knew about. Father Ring said once that I was very unforgiving. I think now he was right. Our family were always vindictive.” After that she began to complain about being nervous alone and Mrs. Cashman offered to sleep with her. “Oh, I could never bear another woman in the room with me,” Polly said impatiently. “What I want is a man. I think I’ll ask Charlie to make it up.” “Is it that fellow?” cried Charlie’s mother, aghast. “That scut—that—I have no words for him. Oh, my! A man that would shame his poor wife the way that ruffian did!” “Ah, the way ye talk one’d think he never stopped,” Polly said fractiously. “Ye have as much old goings-on about one five minutes!” At this Mrs. Cashman decided she was going soft in the head. When a married woman begins to reckon her husband’s infidelities in terms of hours and minutes she is in a bad state. Polly asked Charlie meekly enough to come back and keep her company. Charlie would have been as well pleased to stay as he was, where he could come and go as he liked, but he saw it was some sort of change before death. It was cold comfort for Polly. Too much mischief had been made between them for Charlie to feel about her as a man should feel for his wife. They would lie awake in the grey, flickering light of the colza-oil lamp, with all the holy pictures round them and the Lourdes clock on the mantelpiece ticking away whenever it remembered it and making wild dashes to catch up on lost time, and Charlie’s thoughts would wander and he would think that if Polly were once out of the way he would have another chance of a woman who would fling herself into his arms without asking Father Ring’s permission, like the Yeoman Captain’s daughter in the old song: _A thousand pounds I’ll give thee And fly from home with thee; I’ll dress myself in man’s attire And fight for Liberty._ Charlie was a romantic, and he couldn’t get over his boyish notion that there must be women like the Captain’s Daughter, if only you could meet them. And while he was making violent love to her, Polly, lying beside him, thought of how her poor bare bones would soon be scattered in the stony little patch above Kilmurray while another woman would be lying in her bed. It made her very bitter. “I suppose you’re only waiting till the sod is over me?” she said one night in a low voice when Charlie was just fancying that she must have dropped off. “What’s that?” he asked in astonishment and exasperation, looking at her with one arm under her head, staring into the shadows. “You’re only waiting till I’m well rotten to get another woman in my place,” she went on accusingly. “What a thing I’d think of!” Charlie snapped, as cross as a man jolted out of his sleep, for her words had caught the skirts of the Captain’s Daughter as she slipped out of the room, and Charlie felt it was shameful for him in his health and strength to be contriving like that against a sick woman. “Nothing matters to you now only to best John Joe and have a son that’ll come in for the shop,” said Polly with the terrible insight of the last loneliness. “Only for the shop you might have some nature for me.” “And when the hell had I anything but nature for you?” he shouted indignantly, sitting up. “What do you think I married you for? Money?” “If you had any nature for me you wouldn’t disrespect me,” Polly went on stubbornly, clinging to her grievance. “And what about you?” said Charlie. “You had to think I was some old devil on the pictures before you could put up with me. There’s nature for you!” “I did it with a good object,” said Polly. “Good object!” snorted Charlie. He almost told her that Juliet and the Captain’s Daughter didn’t do it with a good object or any object at all only getting the man they wanted, but he knew she wouldn’t understand. Polly lay for a long time drawing deep breaths through her nose. “Don’t think or imagine I’ll rest quiet and see you married to another woman,” she added in a very determined voice. “You may think you’ll be rid of me but I’ll make full sure you won’t. All our family would go to hell’s gates to be revenged.” “Christ Almighty,” snarled Charlie, giving one wild leap out of the bed, “leave me out of this! This is my thanks for coming back here! Leave me out!” “Mind what I say now,” said Polly in an awe-inspiring voice, pointing a bony arm at him from the shadows. She knew she had him on a sore spot. Herself or Mrs. Cashman would have made no more fuss about meeting a ghost than about meeting the postman, but Charlie had enough of the rationalist in him to be terrified. His mother had brought him up on them. “Our family was ever full of ghosts,” she added solemnly. “You won’t have much comfort with her.” “My trousers!” cried Charlie, beside himself with rage and terror. “Where the hell is my trousers?” “I’m giving you fair warning,” Polly cried in blood-curdling tones as he poked his way out of the room in his nightshirt. “I’ll soho ye well, the pair of ye!” IX She died very peacefully one evening when no one was in the room but old Mrs. Cashman. Even in death she made trouble for Charlie. Her last wish was to be buried in Closty, the Donegan graveyard. It wasn’t that she bore any malice to Charlie, but the thought of the two wives in one grave upset her. She said it wouldn’t be nice, and Nora agreed with her. Of course, when it got out it made things worse for Charlie, for it suggested that, at the very least, he had some hand in her death. Nora felt rather like that too, but then a strange thing happened. She was coming down from the bedroom when she heard a noise from the shop. The door was closed, all but an inch or two, but Nora was of a very inquisitive disposition. She pushed it in. The shop was dark, several of the outside shutters being up, but in the dim light she saw the figure of a man and realized that the noise she had heard was weeping. It gave her a shock, for it had never once occurred to her that Charlie was that sort of man. She was a warm-hearted girl. She went up and touched his arm. “I’m sorry, Charlie,” she said timidly. “I know that, Nora,” he muttered without looking round. “I know you are.” “She’ll be a terrible loss,” she added, more from want of something to say than the feeling that she was speaking the truth. “Ah, she was unfortunate, Nora,” Charlie said with a sob. “She was a fine woman, a lovely woman. I don’t know what bad luck was on us.” “What better luck could ye have and the poor orphan cheated?” cried a harsh, inexpressive voice from the hall. Nora started. Mrs. Cashman was standing in the doorway with her hands on her hips. Her voice and appearance were like those of an apparition, and for the first time Nora wondered if there wasn’t something in Polly’s fancy that she was really a witch. “She’s better off, Nora girl.” “I suppose so,” Nora agreed doubtfully, resenting her intrusion just at the moment when Charlie was ready for confidences. People with tears in their eyes will tell you things they’d never tell you at other times. “She was a good girl and a just girl and she loved her God,” hissed Mrs. Cashman, aiming every word at Charlie under Nora’s guard. “It would be a bad man that would go against her dying wishes.” “Who talked of going against them?” snarled Charlie with the savagery of a goaded beast, and lunging past them went out and banged the hall door behind him. “Poor Charlie is very upset,” said Nora. “Upset?” cackled Mrs. Cashman. “How upset he is! She’s not in her grave yet, and already he’s planning who he’ll get instead of her. That’s how upset he is! But he’s not done with me yet, the blackguard!” For the first time it occurred to Nora that perhaps Charlie had been misjudged—if men could ever be misjudged. From all accounts of what they did to poor women when they had them stripped, they could not, but something about Mrs. Cashman made her suspicious. She went to the funeral in Mrs. Cashman’s carriage. The moment she got out of it at the graveyard she knew there was trouble in store. The Donegans were there, a half dozen different families, and on their own ground they had taken complete command. Charlie was only an outsider. He stood by the hearse with his hands crossed before him, holding his hat, and a look of desperation on his dark face. Others besides herself had noticed the signs, and a group of men was standing in a semicircle a hundred yards down the road, where they wouldn’t get involved. Her father was between them and the hearse, but sufficiently far away to keep out of it as well. He was scowling, his lips pouted, his eyes were half shut while he noticed everything that went on. The procession into the graveyard would be the signal. Charlie would be shouldered away from the cemetery gate, and he knew it, and knew he was no match for half a dozen men younger than himself. He’d fight, of course; everyone who knew Charlie knew that, but he could be very quickly dragged down the lane and no one much the wiser. Just at the moment when the coffin was eased out of the hearse and four Donegans got under it Nora left Mrs. Cashman’s side and stood by Charlie. It was exactly as though she had blown a policeman’s whistle. Her father raised his head and beckoned to the semicircle of men behind and then, pulling the lapels of his coat together, placed himself at the other side of her. One by one half a dozen middle-aged men came up and joined Charlie’s party. They were all old Volunteers and could not stand aside and let their commandant and vice-commandant be hustled about by the seed of land-grabbers and policemen. Not a word was spoken, not a cross look exchanged, but everyone knew that sides had been taken and that Charlie could now enter the graveyard unmolested. As he and Nora emerged at the grave Father Ring looked up at them from under his bushy brows. He had missed none of the drama. There was very little that foxy little man missed. “Thanks, Nora, thanks,” said Charlie in a low voice as the service ended. “You were always a good friend.” Even Nora at her most complacent wouldn’t have described herself as a friend of Charlie’s, but the fact that he had understood what she had done proved him to have better feelings than she had given him credit for. She was embarrassed by the feelings she had roused. The old volunteers all came up and shook her formally by the hand. Her father was the most surprising of all. He stood aside sniffing, with tears in his eyes, too overcome even to tell her what he felt. After that, everyone noticed the change in Charlie. His clothes were brushed, his boots were polished, his face was shaved, and no matter what hour of the morning you went in he had collar and tie on. He spent more time in the shop and less in Johnny Desmond’s. He even gave up going to Johnny’s altogether. That could only mean that he was looking for someone to take Polly’s place. But who would have him? A respectable woman would be lowering herself. The general impression was that he’d marry Molly O’Regan, and Nora supposed that this would only be right, but somehow she couldn’t help feeling it would be a pity. Mrs. Cashman, who saw all her beautiful plans for her grandchildren go up in smoke, felt the same. For the first time Nora included Charlie in her prayers, and asked the Holy Ghost to help him in making the right choice. One night a few weeks later on her way back from the church she looked in on him. She was astonished at Mrs. Cashman’s sourness. “You’ll have a cup of tea?” said Charlie. “I won’t Charlie, honest,” she said hastily, alarmed at the puss the old woman had on her. “I’m rushing home.” “I’ll see you home,” he said at once, giving himself a glance in the mirror. “If you’re back before me, the key will be in the window,” Mrs. Cashman said sourly. “You’re not going out again?” he asked. “I’m not going to stop in this house alone,” she bawled. “Really, Charlie, there’s no reason for you to come,” said Nora in distress. “Nonsense!” he snapped crossly. “Herself and her ghosts!” It was a moonlit night and the street was split with silver light. The abbey tower was silhouetted against it, and the light broke through the deeply splayed chancel lancets, making deep shadows among the foundered tombstones. “I only came to know how you were getting on,” she said. “Ah, I’m all right,” said Charlie. “Only a bit lonesome, of course.” “Ah,” she said with a half-smile, “I suppose you won’t be long that way.” She could have dropped dead with shame as soon as she had said it. Nora was never one to make any bones about her inquisitiveness, but this sounded positively vulgar. It wasn’t in line at all with her behaviour at the funeral. Charlie didn’t seem to notice. He gave her a long look through screwed-up eyes, and then crossed the road to lean his back against the bridge. “Tell me, Nora,” he asked, folding his arms and looking keenly at her from under the peal of his cap, “what would you do in my position?” “Oh, I don’t know, Charlie,” she replied in alarm, wondering how she could extricate herself from the consequences of her own curiosity. “What’s to prevent you?” “You know the sort of things Polly said?” he said with a sigh. “I don’t think I’d mind that at all,” she replied. “After all, Polly was a very sick woman.” “She was,” agreed Charlie. “Do you think ’twould be right to go against her wishes like that?” “Well, of course, that would depend, Charlie,” said Nora with sudden gravity, for like many of her race she combined a strong grasp of the truths of religion with a hazy notion of the facts of life. “You mean on whether ’twas done with a good object or not?” Charlie asked keenly. All he had learned from years with Polly was the importance of doing things with a good object. “And whether the wishes were reasonable or not,” she added, surprised to find him so well-versed in religious matters. “And you don’t think they were?” “I wouldn’t say so. Father Ring could tell you that better than I could.” “I dare say, I dare say. Tell me, Nora, do you believe in things like that?” “Like what, Charlie?” she asked in surprise. “Ghosts, and things of that sort,” he said with a nervous glance in the direction of the abbey, whose slender tapering tower soared from the rubbish-tip of ruined gables, with its tall irregular battlements that looked like cockades in the moonlight. “We’re taught to believe in them,” she replied with a little shudder. “I know we are,” sighed Charlie. “But you never saw one yourself ?” “I didn’t.” “Nor I.” They resumed their walk home. Nora saw now what was fretting him. Polly had said she’d haunt him and Polly was a woman of her word. Anything she had ever said she’d do she had done, and there was no saying that as a pure spirit she’d have changed much. Charlie himself had lost a lot of the cocksure rationalism of his fighting days. He had lived so long with women that he was becoming almost as credulous as they. He was reckoning up his chances in case Polly’s ghost got out of hand. Nora couldn’t give him much comfort, for her own belief in ghosts was determined by the time of day, and at ten o’clock of a moonlight night is was always particularly strong. When they parted she blamed herself a lot. It was most unmaidenly of her first to call at all and, secondly, to ask point blank what his intentions were, for that was what it amounted to, and for a terrible few minutes she had dreaded that he might think it mattered to her. Of course it didn’t, except for his own sake, because though she had begun to like him better, she knew there was no possibility of a Child of Mary like herself marrying him—even if Polly had been an unobtrusive ghost. She would have been surprised and upset to know that her views were not shared by others. When Charlie got home he stood in the hall in surprise. There was something queer about the house. The hall was in darkness; there was light in the kitchen but it was very feeble. With all the talk of ghosts it upset him. “Are you there, mother?” he called nervously, but there was no reply, only the echo of his own voice. He went to the kitchen door and his heart almost stopped beating. The fire was out, the greater part of the room in shadow, but two candles in two brass candlesticks were burning on the mantelpiece, and between them, smiling down at him, a large, silver-framed photo of Polly. Next moment, seeing how he was being baited, he went mad with rage. His mother, the picture of aged innocence, was kneeling by her bed when he went in, and she looked round at him in surprise. “Was it you left that in the kitchen?” he shouted. “What is it?” she asked in mock ignorance, rising and screwing up her eyes as she reached for the picture. “Oh, isn’t it pretty?” she asked. “I found it today in one of her drawers.” “Put it back where you found it,” he stormed. “Oye, why?” she asked with a pretence of concern. “Wouldn’t anyone like it—his poor, dead wife? Unless he’d have something on his conscience.” “Never mind my conscience,” shouted Charlie. “Fitter for you to look after your own.” “Aha,” she bawled triumphantly, throwing off the mask, “my conscience have nothing to trouble it.” “You have it too well seasoned.” “And don’t think but she sees it all, wherever she is,” the old woman cried, raising her skinny paw in the direction in which Polly might be supposed to exist. “Take care she wouldn’t rise from the grave and haunt you, you and that litle whipster you were out gallivanting with!” “What gallivanting?” snarled Charlie. “You don’t know what you’re talking about.” “Maybe I’m blind!” bawled his mother. “Walking into the graveyard alongside you, as if she had you caught already! Aha, the sly-boots, the pussycat, with her novenas and her Nine Fridays! She thinks we don’t know what she’s up to, but God sees ye, and the dead woman sees ye, and what’s more, I see ye. And mark my words, Charlie Cashman, that’s the hand that’ll never rock a cradle for you!” x Two days later Charlie happened to be serving behind the counter when he saw Father Ring busily admiring the goods in the shop window. The priest smiled and nodded, but when Charlie made to come out to him he shook his head warningly. Then he raised one finger and pointed in the direction of the house door. Charlie nodded gloomily. Father Ring made another sign with his thumb to indicate the direction he was going in and Charlie nodded again. He knew Father Ring wanted to talk to him somewhere his mother wouldn’t know. He found Father Ring letting on to be studying the plant life in the river. When Charlie appeared he indicated surprise and pleasure at such an unexpected meeting. “Whisper, Charlie,” he said at last, putting his left hand on Charlie’s shoulder and bending his head discreetly across the other one, “I had a visit from your mother.” “My mother?” “Your mother,” the priest said gravely, studying his face again before making another little excursion over his shoulder. “She’s afraid you’re going to get married again,” he whispered in amusement. “She’s easy frightened.” “That’s what I told her. I know you’ll keep this to yourself. She seems to think there’s some special commandment to stop you. Of course,” added the priest with a shocked air, “I told her I wouldn’t dream of interfering.” “You did to be sure,” said Charlie watchfully, knowing that this was the one thing in the world that no one could prevent Father Ring from doing. “You know the girl I mean?” “I do.” “A nice girl.” “A fine girl.” “And a courageous girl,” said Father Ring. “Mind you, ’tisn’t every girl would do what she did the day of the funeral. Of course,” he admitted, “she should have been married ten years ago. They get very contrairy.” Then he pounced. “Tell me, Charlie, you wouldn’t be thinking about her, would you? I’m not being inquisitive?” “You’re not, to be sure.” “Because it struck me that if you were, I might be able to do you a good turn. Of course, she hasn’t much experience. You know what I mean?” “I do, father,” said Charlie who realized as well as the priest did that it would be no easy job to coax a pious girl like Nora into marriage with a public sinner like himself. But at the same time he was not going to be bounced into anything. He had made a fool of himself once before. “Well now,” he added with a great air of candour, turning towards the river as though for recollection, “I’ll tell you exactly the way I’m situated, father. You know the old saying: ‘Once bitten, twice shy.’” “I do, I do,” said Father Ring, turning in the same direction as if his thought and Charlie’s might meet and mingle over the river. Then he started and gave Charlie a look of astonishment. “Ah, I wouldn’t say that, Charlie.” “Well, maybe I’m putting it a bit strongly, father.” “I think so, Charlie, I think you are,” Father Ring said eagerly. “I’d say she was a different class altogether. More feminine, more clinging—that’s under the skin, of course. “You might be right, father,” Charlie said but he stuck to his point all the same. “But there’s one thing you might notice about me,” he went on, looking at the priest out of the corner of his eye. “You mightn’t think it but I’m a highly strung man.” “You are, you are,” said Father Ring with great anxiety. “I noticed that myself. I wonder would it be blood pressure, Charlie?” “I was never the same since the Troubles,” said Charlie. “But whatever it is, I want something to steady me.” “You do, you do,” said the priest, trying to follow his drift. “If I had a family I’d be different.” “You would,” said Father Ring with a crucified air. “I can see you’re a domesticated sort of man.” “And,” added Charlie with a wealth of meaning in his tone, “if the same thing happened me again I might as well throw myself in there.” He pointed at the river, scowling, and then took a deep breath and stepped back from the priest. “But you don’t think it would, Charlie?” “But you see, father, I don’t know.” “You don’t, you don’t, to be sure you don’t,” said Father Ring in a glow of understanding. “I see it now. And, of course, having doubts like that, they might come against you.” “You put your finger on it.” “And, of course, if you were to marry the other girl—what’s that her name is?—Peggy or Kitty or Joan, you’d have no doubts, and, as well as that, you’d have the little fellow. You could look after him.” “That’s the very thing, father,” Charlie said savagely. “That’s what has me demented.” “It has, it has, of course,” said Father Ring, smiling at the sheer simplicity of it. “Of course, Nora is a nicer girl in every way but a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. I know exactly how you feel. I’d be the same myself.” So Charlie returned to the shop, feeling worse than ever. Nora, as Father Ring said, was a nice girl, but a bird in the hand was worth two in the bush and Charlie felt he never really had a bird of any breed; nothing but a few tailfeathers out of Molly before she flew into the bush after the others. And even Father Ring didn’t know how badly he felt about Molly’s son. He was a warm-hearted man; how else could he feel? Once he had got out the car and driven to the village where the boy had been nursed, watched him come home from school, and then followed him to slip a half crown into his hand. If only he could bring the little fellow home and see him go to a good school like a Christian, Charlie felt he could put up with a lot from Molly. And he knew that he wouldn’t really have to put up with much from her. Under normal circumstances, there was no moral or intellectual strain that Molly could be subjected to which could not be cured by a hearty smack on the backside. But then his mind would slip a cog and he would think of the scene outside the graveyard, and Nora, grave and pale, stepping over to his side. “In comes the Captain’s Daughter, the Captain of the Yeos”; “Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo?”—a couple of lines like those and Charlie would feel himself seventeen again, ready to risk his life for Ireland or anything else that came handy. Whatever misfortune was on him, he knew his mother was right all the time; that he could never be like any other sensible man but would keep on to the day he died, pining for something a bit larger than life. That night the temptation to go to the pub was almost irresistible. He went as far as the door and then walked on. That was where people went only when their problems had grown too much for them. Instead he went for a lonesome stroll in the country, and as he returned his feet, as if by magic, led him past Nora’s door. He passed that too, and then turned back. “God bless all here,” he said pushing in the door. She was sitting in the dusk and rose to meet him, flushed and eager. “Come in, Charlie,” she said with real pleasure in her tone. “You’ll have a cup?” “I’ll have a bucket,” said Charlie. “Since I gave up the booze I have a throat like a lime-kiln.” “And did you give it up entirely?” she asked with awe. “Entirely,” said Charlie. “There’s no other way of giving it up.” “Aren’t you great?” she said, but Charlie didn’t know whether he was or not. Like all worriers he had at last created a situation for himself that he could really worry about. As she rose to light the gas he stopped her, resting his big paws on her shoulder. “Sit down,” he said shortly. “I want to have a word with you.” Her face grew pale and her big brown eyes took on a wide, unwinking stare as she did what he told her. If Charlie could only have forgotten his own problem for a moment he would have realized that Nora had also hers. Her problem was what she would say if he asked her to marry him, “I’m in great trouble,” he said. “Oh, Law!” she exclaimed, “What is it?” “I had a talk with Father Ring today.” “I heard about that.” (There was very little she didn’t hear about.) “He wanted me to get married.” “’Tisn’t much when you say it quick,” said Nora with rising colour. From Charlie’s announcement that he was in trouble she had naturally concluded that Father Ring wanted him to marry Molly and, now that it had come to the point, she didn’t really want him to marry Molly. “I wonder how people can have the audacity to interfere in other people’s business like that.” “Ah, well,” said Charlie, surprised at her warmth, “he intended it as a kindness.” “It mightn’t turn out to be such a kindness,” said Nora. “That’s the very thing,” said Charlie. “It might not turn out to be a kindness. That’s what I wanted to ask your advice about. You know the way I’m situated. I’m lonely down there with no one only the mother. I know it would probably be the makings of me, but ’tis the risk that has me damned. ’Twould be different if I knew I was going to have a family, someone to come in for the business when I’m gone.” “You mean the same thing as happened with Polly might happen with her?” Nora exclaimed in surprise. “I mean I broke my heart once before,” snapped Charlie, “and I don’t want to do it again.” “But you don’t think the same thing would happen again?” she asked with a hypnotised air. “But I don’t know, girl, I don’t know,” Charlie cried desperately. “You might think I’m being unreasonable, but if you went through the same thing with a man that I went through with Polly you’d feel the same. Did Polly ever tell you she thought the mother was putting spells on her?” he added sharply. “She did.” “And what do you think of it?” “I don’t know what to think, Charlie,” said Nora, the dusk having produced its periodical change in her views of the supernatural. “When I married Polly first,” Charlie went on reflectively, “she said: ‘Many a better cake didn’t rise.’ The other night she said: “That’s the hand that’ll never rock a cradle for you.’” He looked at Nora to see if she was impressed, but seeing that Nora in her innocent way applied his mother’s prophecy to Molly O’Regan she wasn’t as impressed as she might have been if she had known it referred to herself. Charlie felt the scene wasn’t going right, but he couldn’t see where the error lay. “What knowledge would a woman like that have?” he asked. “I couldn’t imagine, Charlie,” replied Nora with nothing like the awe he expected. “So you see the way I am,” he went on after a moment. “If I don’t marry her—always assuming she’d have me, of course,” he interjected tactfully—“I’m cutting my own throat. If I do marry her and the same thing happens again, I’m cutting her throat as well as my own. What can I do?” “I’m sure I couldn’t advise you, Charlie,” replied Nora steadily, almost as though she was enjoying his troubles, which in a manner of speaking—seeing that her premises were wrong—she was. “What do you think yourself?” Charlie didn’t quite know what to think. He had come there expecting at least as much sympathy and understanding as he had received from Father Ring. He had felt that even a few tears and kisses wouldn’t be out of place. “If she was a different sort of girl,” he said with an infinity of caution, “I’d say to her what I said to Father Ring and ask her to come to Dublin with me for a couple of days.” “But for what, Charlie?” asked Nora with real interest. “For what?” repeated Charlie in surprise. Charlie was under the illusion most common among his countrymen that his meaning was always crystal-clear. “Nora,” he went on with a touch of pathos, “I’ll be frank with you. You’re the only one I can be frank with. You’re the only friend I have in the world. My position is hopeless. Hopeless! Father Ring said it himself. ‘Marrying a girl with doubts like that, what can you expect, Charlie?’ There’s only one thing that would break the spell—have the honeymoon first and the marriage after.” It was dark, but he watched her closely from under the peak of his cap and saw that he had knocked her flat. No one had ever discussed such a subject with Nora before. “But wouldn’t it be a terrible sin, Charlie?” she asked with a quaver in her voice. “Not if ’twas done with a good object,” Charlie said firmly, answering her out of her own mouth. “I’m sure she’d do it even without that, Charlie,” Nora said with sudden bitterness. “If she loved me she would,” said Charlie hopefully. “Love?” cried Nora scornfully, springing from her chair, all her maiden airs dropping from her and leaving her a mature, raging, jealous woman. “Don’t be deceiving yourself like that, my dear man. That one doesn’t love you.” “What? Who? Who doesn’t love me?” asked Charlie in stupefaction. It was her turn then. “Weren’t you talking about Molly O’Regan?” she asked in alarm. “Molly O’Regan?” Charlie cried, raising his face to the ceiling like a dog about to bay. “What the hell put Molly O’Regan into your head, woman? Sure, I could have Molly O’Regan in the morning and the child along with her. Isn’t that what I was saying to you?” “Oh,” said Nora, drawing back from him with a look of horror, “don’t say any more!” “But my God, girl,” moaned Charlie, thinking of his beautiful scene absolutely wasted and impossible to begin on again, “sure you must know I don’t give a snap of my fingers for Molly O’Regan! You were the first woman I ever gave a damn about, only you wouldn’t have me. I only married Polly because she was your shadow. Even Father Ring knew that.” “Oh,” she cried as if she were just ready to go into hysterics, “I couldn’t do it! I couldn’t!” “No, no, no, no,” said Charlie in alarm as though such an idea had never crossed his mind. “You’re taking me up wrong. Whisht, now, whisht, or you’ll be heard!” “You must never, never say such a thing to me again,” she said, looking at him as though he were a devil in human shape. “But my God, woman,” he cried indignantly, “I didn’t. You’re missing the whole point. I never asked you. I said if you were a different sort of woman I might ask you. I was only putting the case the way I put it to Father Ring. Surely you can understand that?” It seemed she couldn’t, not altogether anyhow, and Charlie strode to the door, his hands clasped behind his back and a gloomy look on his face. “I’m sorry if I upset you,” he snapped over his shoulder. “’Tis your own fault didn’t marry me first. You’re the only woman I ever cared about and I wanted to explain.” She was staring at him incredulously, brushing back the loose black hair from her forehead with an uncertain hand. She looked childish and beautiful. If Charlie had only known, she was thinking what a very queer way the Holy Ghost had answered her prayer. As Polly had once said the Lord’s ways were very peculiar. Charlie waited for some sign of relenting in her but saw none and, heaving a deep sigh, he left. Crossing the bridge when the abbey tower was all black and spiky against the sky and the lights in the back of the little shops were reflected in the river, he was like a man demented. He had done it again! This time he’d done it for good. It would soon be in everyone’s mouth that he had tried to seduce a second girl. He knew how it would be interpreted. He saw it already like headlines in a newspaper: WELL-KNOWN SHOPKEEPER’S SHOCKING PROPOSAL OUTRAGED FATHER’S INDIGNATION. The girl who had stood by him when no one else would do it—this was her thanks! And it all came of Romeo and Juliet, the Captain’s Daughter and the rest of the nonsense. There was a curse on him. Nora would tell her father and Father Ring; between them they would raise up a host of new enemies against him; no one would do business with him—a foolish, idle, dreamy, impractical man! XI He let a week go by before he did anything. In that time he realized the full horror of the scrape he had got himself into, and avoided every contact with people he knew. He spent most of his time in the sitting-room, and only went down to the shop when the girl came up for him and he knew that the visitor was a genuine customer and not an angel of vengeance. Finally, he asked Jim O’Regan in for a drink. Jim was an ex-soldier, small, gaunt, and asthmatic, dressed in a blue serge suit that was no bluer than his face and with a muffler high about his throat. Johnny Desmond gave them a queer look as they entered, but Charlie, seemingly in the highest spirits, rattled away about everything till it dawned on them both that he had opened negotiations for Molly and the child. Charlie could have gone further but one glance at Jim’s mean poker face and he remembered the scene outside the graveyard, and then it was as if Holy Ireland, Romeo and Juliet, and all the romantic dreams of his youth started with a cry from their slumber. It was terrible, but he couldn’t help it; he was an unfortunate dreamy man. Later that morning he had to go to the bank. The whole week he had been putting it off, but he could put it off no longer. He gave a quick glance up the street to see that the coast was clear and then strode briskly out. He hadn’t gone a hundred yards when he saw Jerry Lawlor coming down the same pavement. Charlie looked round frantically for some lane or shop he could take refuge in but there was none. “Brass, boys, brass!” he groaned. But to his great surprise Jerry showed no signs of anger, only a slight surprise at Charlie’s slinking air. “Good morrow, Charlie,” he said, sticking his thumbs in the armholes of his vest, “as you won’t say it yourself,” he added jovially. “Oh, good morrow, good morrow, Jerry,” cried Charlie with false heartiness, trying to read the signs on Jerry’s battered countenance. “Up to the bank I’m rushing,” he said confidentially. “The bank?” Jerry said slyly. “Not the presbytery?” “What the hell would I be doing at the presbytery?” Charlie exclaimed with a watchful smile. “Oh, headquarters, headquarters,” replied Jerry. “Who was it was telling me you were thinking of taking the field again? I believe your patrols were out.” “Patrols, Jerry?” Charlie echoed in surprise. “Ah, I’m too old for soldiering.” “I hope not, Charlie,” said Jerry. “Begor,” he added, squaring his shoulders, “I don’t know that I’d mind shouldering the old shotgun again in a good cause. Well, be good!” he ended with a wink and a nod. He left Charlie open-mouthed on the pavement, looking after him. What the blazes did Jerry Lawlor mean? he wondered, scratching his poll. “Be good”—was that the sort of advice you’d expect from a man whose daughter you had just been trying to seduce? “Be good”—was the man mad or something? He couldn’t understand why Jerry, who had the devil’s own temper, took his advances to Nora in that spirit. Was it possible that Nora had censored them so much that he hadn’t understood? Was it—a wild hope—that she hadn’t told him at all? His face fell again. No woman could keep a thing like that to herself. If she hadn’t told her father, she’d told someone else, and sooner or later it would get back to him. He heaved a bitter sigh. The sooner he could fix up things with the O’Regans the sooner he would be armed to face the attack. He went on, but his luck seemed to be dead out that morning. As he went in the door Father Ring came out. Charlie gave him a terrified look, but before he could even think of escape, Father Ring was shaking his hand. “You’re looking well, Charlie.” “I’m not feeling too good, father,” said Charlie, thinking how far from the truth it was. “Tell me,” said Father Ring confidentially, “you didn’t do any more about that little matter we were discussing?” “To tell you the truth, father,” Charlie said with apparent candour, “I didn’t.” “Take your time,” Father Ring said with a knowing look. “There’s no hurry. I wouldn’t be surprised if something could be done about that kid of yours. Mind! I’m not making any promises, but there’s a soft corner there for you all right, and the father wouldn’t let her go empty-handed. You know what I mean?” “I do, father,” groaned Charlie, meaning that he hadn’t a notion, and as Father Ring went round the corner towards the church he stood on the bank steps with his head in a whirl. It was a spring day, a sunshiny day which made even the main street look cheerful, but Charlie was too confused for external impressions. For a week he had skulked like an assassin from Jerry Lawlor and Father Ring, yet here they treated him like lovers. And Nora went to confession to Father Ring! Admitting that he wouldn’t let on what she did tell him, he couldn’t conceal what she didn’t, and it was quite plain that she hadn’t told either of them about Charlie. Now what purpose would a girl have in concealing a thing like that? Modesty? But modesty in Charlie’s mind was associated with nothing but hullabaloo. There was another flash of hope like a firework in his head, and then again darkness. “Christ!” he thought despairingly. “I’m going dotty! ’Tis giving up the drink in such a hurry.” “Morra, Charlie,” said a farmer going in, but Charlie didn’t even acknowledge the salute. His face was screwed up like that of a man who has forgotten what he came for. Then he drew a deep breath, pulled himself erect, and set off at a brisk pace for the Lawlors’. Nora came out when she heard him banging on the door and gaped at him with horror-stricken eyes. He pushed her rudely back into the kitchen before him. “Sit down, sit down!” he said shortly. “What would I sit down for?” she asked in a low voice, and then her knees seemed to give way and she flopped. “When can you marry me?” asked Charlie, standing over her like a boxer, ready to knock her flat if she rose again. “Why?” she asked in a dead voice. “Wouldn’t Molly O’Regan have you?” “Ha, ha,” laughed Charlie bitterly. “I see the tomtoms were working this morning.” “I suppose you think we don’t know that ’tis all arranged?” she asked, throwing back her head to toss aside the stray curl that fell across her face. “The trouble with you,” Charlie said vindictively, “is that you always know other people’s business and never know your own. When you met the one man that cared for you you let him slip. That’s how much you knew. You’re trying to do the same thing now.” “If you cared for me you wouldn’t ask me to disrespect myself,” she said with mournful accusation. “If I didn’t, I wouldn’t ask you at all,” snapped Charlie. “Now, I’m asking you properly. Once and for all, will you marry me?” “But why should you?” she asked in a vague hysterical tone, rising with her hands thrown out and her head well back. “You know now the sort of woman I am. You need never respect me any more.” “What the hell is up with you?” shouted Charlie, almost dancing with fury. Whatever he said to this girl seemed to be wrong. “There’s nothing up with me,” she answered in a reasonable tone which was as close to lunacy as anything Charlie had ever heard. “I know what I am now—that’s all.” “And what are you?” asked Charlie in alarm. “You ought to know,” she said triumphantly. “I didn’t slap your face, did I?” “You didn’t what?” cried Charlie with an agonized look. “Oh,” she cried in a rapture of self-abasement, “I deceived myself nicely all the years. I thought I was a good-living woman but you knew better. You knew what I was; a cheap, vulgar, sensual woman that you could say what you liked to. Or do what you liked to. I suppose it’s the just punishment for my pride. Why would you marry me when you can get me for nothing?” Charlie had another flash of inspiration, this time inspiration mixed with pity and shame. He suddenly saw the girl was fond of him and would do anything for him. Jessica, Juliet, the Captain’s Daughter, the whole blooming issue. This was the real thing, the thing he had always been looking for and never found. He nearly swept her off her feet as he grabbed her. “God forgive me!” he said thickly. “The finest woman in Ireland and I tormenting you like that! Your father and the priest have more sense than me. Put on your things and we’ll go down and see them.” “No, no, no,” she cried hysterically like a Christian martyr offering herself to the lions. “Your mother said I’d never rock a cradle for you.” “My mother, my mother—she has me as bad as herself. Never mind what she says.” “But what’ll you do if she puts spells on me?” she asked in a dazed tone, putting her hand to her forehead. “Roast her over a slow fire,” snapped Charlie. He was himself again, aged seventeen, a roaring revolutionary and rationalist, ready to take on the British Empire, the Catholic Church, and the Wise Woman all together. “Now listen to me, girl,” he said, taking her hands. “No one is going to put spells on you. And no one is going to haunt you, either. That’s only all old women’s talk and we had enough of it to last us our lives. We’re a match for anyone and anything. Now, what are you doing?” “Making the dinner,” said Nora, blinking and smiling at anything so prosaic. “We’ll have dinner in town, the four of us,” said Charlie. “Now come on!” He stood behind her grinning as she put on her hat. She put it on crooked and her face was blotched beyond anything a powderpuff could repair, but Charlie didn’t mind. He felt grand. At last he had got what he had always wanted, and he knew the rest would come. (It did too, and all Mrs. Cashman’s spells didn’t delay it an hour.) As for Nora, she had no notion what she had got, but she had an alarming suspicion that it was the very opposite of what she had always desired. (Which, for a woman, is usually more or less the same thing.) (1947)